Rick Chiang was seven years old, standing in an intensive care unit, when he made himself a promise. His four-year-old sister had fallen, and years later needed three major operations on her neck. He is not against surgery, and says plainly that some operations are genuinely necessary. What concerns him is a step he often finds has been missed in the patients who reach him: looking properly at factors that may be contributing to the pain, and whether they could be settled more gently.
I'm Not Against Surgery. I'm Worried About the Step Before It.
If a doctor has mentioned an operation and the thought of surgery frightens you, I understand that more than you might realise.
A promise made in an intensive care unit
When I was seven, my little sister was four. She fell from a height and hit her head badly.
For years afterwards she seemed a little clumsy, and no one knew why. Then, when she was older, a scan showed a serious problem higher in her neck, near the base of the skull. It was dangerous enough that she needed three major operations, one after another. For a time, she was in a wheelchair.
I still remember standing in the intensive care unit, looking at her. Small tubes and drains everywhere. Her little arms swollen.
I was just a child, watching my whole family go through it. And it was there, in that hospital, that I made myself a promise. That one day I would help people with their pain and their injuries without an operation, wherever there was any way to avoid one.
Years later I became a physiotherapist, and I built Pain Free Physio & Allied Health to keep that promise. It is the reason the clinic exists.
Surgery has its place
Some operations are genuinely necessary. I would never tell you otherwise.
That matters, because a clinic whose mission is to help people pain free naturally without medication, injection and surgery is easy to misread. We are not against operations. My own sister needed three of them, and I am grateful every day that they were available to her.
What concerns me is something different, and much more specific.
The assessment step I often find has been missed
In the patients who come to me, what I see is people being pointed towards surgery before anyone has looked closely at factors that may be contributing to their pain, and whether those factors could be settled more gently first.
In my clinic, I often find nobody has taken that step.
Part of the reason is that the source of the problem isn’t always where you feel the pain. Sometimes factors contributing to back pain can be outside the back, for example, down in the calf muscle. A sore shoulder can be driven from the neck. If nobody assesses you head to toe, factors that may be loading the painful area can go unnoticed for years, and the only remaining conversation is about the painful area itself.
Sometimes the real cause of a person’s pain sits well away from where it hurts. Every person is different, more than one factor can be contributing at once, and a single cause cannot always be identified.
We have seen cases where, once factors contributing to the pain were identified and treated, an operation that was never truly needed was avoided. That is not everyone’s experience, and no assessment can promise it in advance.
Sometimes. Not always. That word is doing a lot of work, because I am not going to promise you an outcome. Some conditions need surgical management and no amount of good physiotherapy changes that. But the question of what may be driving the pain deserves an answer either way, and in my experience it has often not been asked.
What to do if surgery has been raised with you
It does not mean don’t have the operation. That is a decision for you and your medical team, and it should be.
It means there is a question worth asking before you get there. Has anyone looked properly at what may be contributing to this, head to toe, rather than only at the area that hurts?
If the answer is no, that is worth doing first. Not instead of your surgeon. Before them.
Come and ask your questions in person
So if surgery has been raised and it frightens you, please don’t assume it’s your only option before factors that may be contributing have been properly looked at.
Come to one of our free workshops across Brisbane. Bring your family, because these decisions are rarely made alone. Ask whatever you want to ask, with no obligation to book anything afterwards.
If you’d rather start with a quiet conversation, a concierge appointment is a short call with Kayla, our patient concierge (trained as a nurse). She’ll listen to what’s going on and help you work out whether a full assessment is worth booking.
Book here: https://painfreephysio.com/booking/
Two Brisbane clinics: Sunnybank Hills and Robertson.
FAQ
Many patients choose to, and you are entitled to ask. A physiotherapy assessment is not a second surgical opinion, but it answers a different question: what may be driving the pain, and whether anything beyond the painful area has been assessed. That is useful whether you have the operation or not.
Sometimes, and it depends entirely on the condition. Some problems need surgical management and physiotherapy will not change that. Where factors contributing to the pain have not yet been identified, addressing them can sometimes change the picture. Nobody should promise you an outcome before assessing you.
Rather than examining only the area that hurts, the assessment looks at how the whole body is moving and loading, because factors contributing to pain are often somewhere other than the site of it. A sore back can be driven from the calf. A sore shoulder can be coming from the neck.
Not necessarily, though timing matters and you should talk to your surgeon before changing anything. Many patients also choose to see a physiotherapist before an operation so they go in well conditioned. A head to toe assessment is worth having either way.
Yes, and Rick actively encourages it. Decisions about surgery are rarely made alone, and it often helps to have the person who will be supporting you hear the same information at the same time.


